SNAP: ‘Temporary’ work waivers approved for seventh straight year


By William Patrick | Florida Watchdog

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Since 2009, Florida’s most able-bodied recipients of government food assistance have been exempt from work requirements.

The “temporary” waiver will continue in 2015, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which distributes Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits — called food stamps before 2009.

TEMPORARY?: Since 2009, Florida has exempted able-bodied adults without children from meeting work requirements. But the Sunshine State is hardly alone.

As part of the federal Stimulus law, temporary work waivers were given to states to help workers displaced by the financial crisis.

That was nearly six years ago.

Despite significantly improved economic conditions, Florida and 27 other states are set to receive full work requirement exemptions next year, as will Guam, the Virgin Islands and Washington D.C. Fourteen additional states have obtained partial waivers.

Only eight states are choosing not to renew: Delaware, Iowa, Kansas, Maine, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas and Wyoming.

Is this the new normal?

Previously, healthy people between 18 and 50 without children or other dependents could only reap three months of the welfare benefit in a three-year period, unless they worked or participated in a “workfare” program designed to get them work.

That was scrapped when Congress passed the $831 billion stimulus package. Most states have been seeking the added federal assistance ever since.

“About 5 million more people are on government assistance (nationwide) due to this waiver,” Josh Archambault, senior fellow at the Naples-based Foundation for Government Accountability, told Watchdog.

“There was once a bipartisan agreement that able-bodied people should be working in exchange for benefits,” he said.

But that changed when the USDA began offering a number of generous qualifying criteria, mostly based on unemployment rates. Other factors, such as academic studies describing a lack of jobs, are considered.

Florida, more than most states, was hit hard by the recession.

In 2010, when the state unemployment rate averaged nearly 11.2 percent, 2.6 million Floridians were receiving federal SNAP benefits.

In 2014, more than 3.5 million Floridians obtained were enrolled, according to USDA. Florida’s unemployment rate is now 6.3 percent.

Able-bodied childless adults make up an estimated 10 percent of the 47 million Americans receiving some $76 billion in SNAP benefits. In 2000, enrollment included just 17 million individuals.

“There’s been a well-intentioned effort to get people enrolled, but the unintentional consequence may be long-term dependency,” said Archambault. “There’s also a misconception that federal tax dollars are somehow free.”

Watchdog contacted the Florida Department of Children and Families, responsible for administering the SNAP program in Florida, but details as to why the state applied for another were not provided.

“Florida has been approved for the waiver from October 2014 through September 2015. The Food and Nutrition Service has told Florida that this will probably be the last year Florida will meet the criteria since the unemployment rates have continued to show great improvement,” a spokeswoman Michelle Glady said in an email.