EPA regulations likely will kill 68-year-old Louisiana peach orchard


DYING: North Louisiana business owner Joe Mitcham stands in front of what’s left of his peach orchard, ravaged by a particular fungus. A product exists to fix the problem and save his business, but the federal government has phased it out of the market on the grounds that it threatens the ozone layer.

By Chris Butler | Tennessee Watchdog

RUSTON, La. — The peach orchards at Mitcham Farms, near the north Louisiana city of Ruston, have survived winter freezes, droughts and dangerous hail storms, but they evidently will not survive the Environmental Protection Agency and its regulations.

The family-owned business, established in 1946 and featured in tourism magazines, is Louisiana’s largest peach orchard, according to its website, but owner Joe Mitcham expects he’ll close up shop in only a few years.

The federal government’s banning of a chemical in 2005 known as methyl bromide, used to treat diseased peach trees, has really given him no choice, as most of his trees won’t survive without it.

Many of Mitcham’s trees have already died.

The EPA claims using this chemical threatens the earth’s ozone layer.

Mitcham told Watchdog the federal regulations have also forced him to downsize his business from 60 employees to 20.

“Well, with more acreage to use we would be prospering,” Mitcham said. “We had the potential to be a million dollar business, but definitely not now.”

Mitcham said he now has difficulty covering business expenses. While describing himself as upset and frustrated by the situation, Mitcham, who inherited the business from his father, is heading into retirement.

Mitcham’s children are not interested in taking on the family business, but even if they were, the land, with the federal regulations in place, can no longer grow peaches or even other types of fruit, he said.

Selling the business to another potential owner is also not an option, for obvious reasons, nor is buying land elsewhere, given the area’s high property values, Mitcham said.

EPA spokeswoman Enesta Jones told Watchdog on Wednesday that many of the agency’s experts on the subject of methyl bromide are “out of the office this week.”

The peach orchards remain a huge tourism draw, Mitcham said.

“This will have an impact with the loss of jobs and the loss of income of selling the fruit here because we have so many customers coming from out of state, especially Texas,” Mitcham said. “Half the vehicles I saw coming through here on July 4 were Texas license plates. The loss of that economy coming through Ruston will be pretty major.”

Ruston resident Laura Jones is among those upset about the situation.

PEACHY KEEN?: A collection of peaches gathered from north Louisiana.

Jones told Watchdog she went to the farm often growing up, and she now takes her children there.

“The reason more people aren’t in arms over the farm closing is because every time it’s been talked about before was because it seemed to be far away in the future, and not imminent,” Jones said.

“It’s such a symbol of our area, and it’s such a part of our history and it’s such a shame that it would go away. I don’t know what that would mean for our Peach Festival.”

Jones refers to Ruston’s annual Peach Festival, a big tourism draw held every summer for the past 50 years, with at least a little influence from the Mitcham family.

This year’s festival had a $5 million impact on the city of about 22,000 people, said Ruston Lincoln Parish Convention and Visitors Bureau President Judy Copeland.

Copeland told Watchdog some people call her agency confused about whether the festival will continue.

PEACH PERFECT: Ruston, Louisiana's economy thrives on tourism for its yearly Peach Festival and homegrown peaches. Now, because of EPA rules, many peaches at the festival are imported from other states.

PEACH PERFECT: Ruston, Louisiana’s economy thrives on tourism for its yearly Peach Festival and homegrown peaches. Now, because of EPA rules, many peaches at the festival are imported from other states.

Mitcham, though, doesn’t generally bring his own peaches to the festival as he does plenty of business at his farm with the peaches he is still able to grow. The festival will, of course, continue, Copeland said.

“Still, though, we’re losing a big part of our community,” Copeland said. “It’s like losing a family member.”

Mitcham told Watchdog he hasn’t pursued any legal remedies.

Agricultural experts are currently pondering the benefits of an alternative to methyl bromide, but, if approved, no one will sell it until long after Mitcham’s farm is gone, he said.

According to the EPA’s website, methyl bromide is a toxic substance.

The United States and 26 other countries agreed in 1987, through an international treaty, to phase the product out of the market.

Contact Christopher Butler at chris@tennesseewatchdog.org or follow him and submit story ideas on his official Facebook page.

Get regular Tennessee Watchdog updates through our Facebook or Twitter accounts

Click here to get Tennessee Watchdog articles sent directly to your email inbox (click Tennessee under “Watchdog News Updates)

Like Watchdog.org? Click HERE to get breaking news alerts in YOUR state!