Another Loss for #NoDAPL: Judge Rules That Dakota Access Pipeline Can Remain Open

The Dakota Access Pipeline has been open and moving oil for months now, but there was a chance that a federal judge could shut that flow down based on legal maneuvering by the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and the activist lawyers representing them.

Earlier this year federal Judge James Boasberg found that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had deficiencies in their analysis of the pipeline project under NEPA (the National Environmental Protection Act) even though the federal agency had “substantially complied” with the law.

But after months of legal wrangling, Boasberg concluded stopping the oil flow so the Corps could stage a do-over doesn’t make sense since the Corps would probably just reach the same conclusion anyway:

Here’s the conclusion from Boasberg’s opinion, the entirety of which you can read below:

I will never underestimate the ability of left wing environmental groups to find new things to litigate over, but with this opinion I think the last real legal threat to the Dakota Access Pipeline is gone.

It’s here to stay, which is a good thing given that it’s currently pumping about $6 million per month in tax revenues into North Dakota’s coffers.

Here’s the full opinion:

[scribd id=361330071 key=key-t5MqVGMwWVUlc4uKXtJC mode=scroll]

Rob Port is the editor of, a columnist for the Forum News Service, and host of the Plain Talk Podcast which you can subscribe to by clicking here.

Related posts